Sotally Tober
I spent years on and off drugs and alcohol, but I've been sober for six years. I'm just not the same self-centered immature brat I was. Last week, I reached out to my best friend's brother to apologize for things I did about seven years ago. He still hasn't responded to my text (requesting time to talk to make amends). He told my friend he was having a hard time believing I'm any different. But I am, and I want to prove to him I have changed. How can I do that?
--Sincere
He's seen you swear off drugs and alcohol before -- typically for several hours on a Tuesday.
This view he has of you is likely to have some serious staying power. That's because our brain is big on automatic processes -- forming and storing what I call "thinkpacks" so we don't have to put cognitive energy into things we've already figured out. For example, say you do something for the first time, like opening a weird latch on a cupboard. Each time you do it again, the more automatic -- that is, the more unthinking -- opening it becomes.
Believing works similarly. Once we form a belief, we tend to just go with it -- automatically. Questioning a belief, on the other hand, takes mental effort: yanking out our reasoning ability and forcing it to do a bunch of cognitive chores.
Not surprisingly, research by social psychologist Lee Ross, among others, finds that we're prone to taking the mentally easy way out, succumbing to "confirmation bias": clinging to what we already believe and ignoring info that says, "Hey, there just might be a new and improved truth in town."
There's another problem: Our ego is bound up in our clinging to our beliefs -- that is, believing that we were right all along. And though it sounds like you've changed your value system -- which probably bodes well for your staying sober -- if he goes with the idea that you're on the wagon for good, he risks being proved wrong.
The error that you, like many people, make is in thinking, "I'll just change somebody's mind!" and it'll happen pronto. However, consider your goal: apologizing. You can do that by writing a letter. A letter of apology takes an investment of effort that a phoned or texted apology does not -- which makes it more likely to be seen as sincere.
And frankly, if you follow through with the steps for a meaningful apology -- detailing how you wronged him, expressing remorse, and explaining the new values you are now living by -- you lay the best foundation for him to...possibly...someday...believe that you truly have changed.
Sure, it's possible you'll black out again, but maybe just if somebody clocks you for going overboard with the sobervangelizing. It won't be like that time when you were drunk and handcuffed and yelling, "Occifers, I'll have you know that my nickname in middle school was Houdini!"
For pages and pages of "science-help" from me, buy my latest book, "Unf*ckology: A Field Guide to Living with Guts and Confidence." It lays out the PROCESS of transforming to live w/confidence.








As with most drunks and addicts, even when you are trying to make amends, or apologize, its STILL all about what you want. You want forgiveness. You want to prove you are different. If you want to apologize fine, but dont fo it to get something in return. The reason no one believes you is because at your core, you are a narcissist.
Stormy at July 21, 2019 9:38 AM
The guy doesn’t owe the LW his time. It’s great that LW wants to make amends, but it’s probably too little, too late. We don’t have to grant absolution to people who’ve fucked us over. Also, sometimes we forgive people, or at least stop caring about how they’ wronged us, but that doesn’t mean that we want them in our lives again. Write an apology letter, then leave the guy alone.
ahw at July 21, 2019 3:37 PM
The guy doesn’t owe the LW his time. It’s great that LW wants to make amends, but it’s probably too little, too late. We don’t have to grant absolution to people who’ve fucked us over. Also, sometimes we forgive people, or at least stop caring about how they’ wronged us, but that doesn’t mean that we want them in our lives again. Write an apology letter, then leave the guy alone.
ahw at July 21, 2019 3:37 PM
Dude, he doesn't want to talk to you. What you can do is give him the space he so clearly wants.
NicoleK at July 23, 2019 6:19 PM
Oh man, just echoing the above commenters. I had a couple-year casual dating thing (I'm nonmonagamous, he was never a primary partner) with a person who was emotionally controlling and did a pretty good job of hiding a substance abuse problem. He "dumped" me by text frequently and then took me back. I finally ovaried up and responded to one of the dumplings with "Okay, cool, have a nice life."
Lots of begging on his part ensued, I replied more and more tersely until he finally got it.
Years later, he started texting me that he really wanted to meet up. I said yeah, I don't really want to. He kept begging. Finally I said okay, we can meet for coffee. I set up with a friend to call an hour after the planned meetup to give me an easy out "Oh, that was my BFF, she needs me right away."
The "date" was basically him saying his latest girlfriend had dumped him because she said he was emotionally controlling and kind of an asshole. He wanted me to tell him that wasn't true. I said yeah, actually that was kind of my experience too. He argued. I said look, I told you I didn't want to meet up, and you kept pressuring me until I finally gave in, against my better judgment.
I extricated myself. He kept texting and leaving voicemails for the next week or so asking me to meet up again. He asked what it would take to get me to change my mind. Finally, it occurred to me to reply, "You paying me back the money you owe me from when we were dating, that I wrote off because never seeing you again was worth the financial hit." I never heard from him again.
Anathema at July 24, 2019 7:07 AM
Oh my lord, I love it that autocorrect changed "dumpings" to "dumplings." The latter would have made for a far better relationship!
M at July 24, 2019 7:10 AM
Leave a comment