The Sociopath Of Least Resistance
I discovered that the guy I'm dating has a girlfriend he's cheating on. In fact, she confronted us, which was awful. I've had a history of guys cheating on me, and I want to end the pattern. Unfortunately, I'm not attracted to a lot of guys I go out with, and I'm really attracted to this guy.
--Chemistry
Being really attracted to somebody is the go-to excuse for shrugging off a potential partner's shady behavior -- pretty much anything this side of "Well, sure, several of his neighbors are wintering in Ziploc in his basement freezer."
It helps that attraction seems like some mysterious and magical force. It's actually not. Who we're attracted to -- which people, with which features -- is prearranged by our biological robot overlord, aka evolution, via genetic code written into each of us. It's part of evolution's scheme for building better babies -- giving our genes the best shot at being passed on to future generations.
We see this in research by neuropsychologist Bruno Laeng that suggests we are attracted to potential partners who look like us -- though not too much like us. Laeng found that people were most attracted to individuals who share about 22% of their facial features (as opposed to 11% or 33%, the other percentages tested). Other research by social-personality psychologists R. Chris Fraley and Michael J. Marks likewise hit the 22% mark.
Laeng explains that this balancing of "similarity and dissimilarity" (which we do subconsciously) helps us avoid "inbreeding with close relatives," like siblings or first cousins. Inbreeding increases the chances that both partners would have the same nasty recessive genes for a disorder or disease. "Recessive" genes are true to label when they are paired with a dominant gene: They recede...slumping into the background, unemployed, inactive. But when two recessive genes for a condition are paired (like when close relatives with the same recessive gene make a baby), these genes become active -- and so does the disorder or the disease.
As for you, the features you happen to be attracted to come in the package of a guy who cheats on his girlfriend. This reflects bad character. Assuming you didn't go out into Datingland all, "I've just gotta find a sexy sociopath," reflecting on the evolutionary nuts and bolts of attraction might help you stop using it as an excuse and give the shove to Mr. Morally At Leisure.
To avoid again letting the hots for some himbo blind you to his undesirable qualities, make a short checklist -- what I call "man minimums," the qualities you can't do without in a man -- and put character at the top of your list. When a man shows you he comes up short on your "must haves," cut off contact and move on. Ideally, if you're screaming in bed, it isn't because the girlfriend of the guy you're with just burst through the door brandishing a missile launcher.
For pages and pages of "science-help" from me, buy my latest book, "Unf*ckology: A Field Guide to Living with Guts and Confidence." It lays out the PROCESS of transforming to live w/confidence.








Show me the man you can steal from another woman, and I will show you a man that can be stolen from you.
I R A Darth Aggie at March 18, 2020 8:38 AM
If you're going to bring evo psych into this, don't forget that men evolved to spread their genes around as much as they can. The LW is attracted to men who are so attractive to so many women that they find it easy to cheat, and only those of exceptional character are likely to resist the temptation.
I know I wouldn't. I've never cheated on a wife or other committed relationship, but that's because I'm not such a stud muffin that women throw themselves at me, and I'm too lazy to pursue them if I've got someone at home.
Rex Little at March 20, 2020 8:59 AM
I'm reminded of one of your first columns I'd read, "The Mother-in-Law of all Bombs," in which a man wrote you because he was attracted to his mother-in-law. And he wanted to know if he should confront her about this.
You appropriately asked if he was dropped on his head as a child, or if he was looking to get dropped on his head as an adult. You advised him to distract himself whenever inappropriate thoughts of his mother-in-law sneak into his mind.
This is exactly what she needs to do with this cad. Yes, I get that he's hot. I'm sure Anne Boleyn thought Henry VIII was pretty hot, too. Which doesn't change the fact that he arranged for her head and body to go their separate ways with a swift, smooth stroke of a French sword.
"But I'm attracted to this guy!"
Then get over it, before you become the next woman he cheats on.
Patrick at March 20, 2020 7:20 PM
Anne Boleyn did not think he was hot. In fact, she kept tried to marry a couple other guys and Henry sicced his Cardinal Woolsley on them to declare the engagements invalid. She left London to escape him. But when the King is pursuing you so thoroughly you don't have much choice.
NicoleK at March 21, 2020 1:57 AM
While I think it’s possible a guy who has cheated before, even on multiple girlfriends, may not cheat on a new girlfriend, I also don’t think it’s very likely.
My prediction: you’re going to go for him, hoping that you’ll be the one who’ll finally make him decide to quit cheating.
My other prediction: you will be wrong and he will cheat on you.
JD at March 25, 2020 5:41 PM
"I've had a history of guys cheating on me, and I want to end the pattern."
I believe LW knows it would be "a good thing" for the pattern to end, but isn't willing to end it herself. Even after being confronted by his GF she still wants to date this guy! She sounds like a smoker who "knows they should quit," but enjoys it and really doesn't want to.
Mort at May 28, 2020 9:57 AM
Leave a comment