Callous In Wonderland
At family gatherings, my sister-in-law makes critical remarks about my appearance, like my shirt's very low-cut or I might want to lose weight before wearing the dress I have on. She only does this in front of others, and she says she just tells me because she cares about me. It doesn't feel that way. I'd really like her to stop.
--Feeling Attacked
When you're female, junior high never ends. The Hello Kitty knife in your back just gets upgraded to one by Cuisinart.
Women are said to be the "gentler sex," because we rarely see one drag another out of the bar by her ponytail for a parking lot beatdown. But women aren't better people than men. Female-on-female aggression just plays out differently -- less visibly, less identifiably -- than the male-on-male kind.
Psychologist Anne Campbell explains that women evolved to avoid direct confrontation -- physical fights or calling somebody out to their face -- and instead compete with other women through sneaky "indirect aggression." This is aggression that doesn't quite read as aggression, like the public shaming that wears the plastic nose and glasses of concern.
Another popular form of woman-on-woman sneaky sabotage is spreading mean gossip to knock another woman down the social ladder and maybe even get her ostracized. There's also "constructive criticism" -- supposedly well-intentioned remarks meant to stress a woman out, make her feel bad about herself, and get her to dim her shine.
Campbell believes women's tendency to use indirect aggression is "a result of their higher parental investment" -- the fact that they're the home and ground transportation for the developing fetus and are children's primary caretakers. A physical fight (or more male-style fighting words that led to a punchout-fest) could damage a woman's reproductive parts or kill her, and an ancestral woman's survival was key to her children's survival and to her passing on her genes.
People like you, who are repeatedly victimized by another person, often don't realize they never set any boundaries, never told the abuser to stop. This effectively sends their tormentor a message: "OPEN SEASON ON ME FOREVER! Keep doin' what you're doin'!"
Whenever your sister-in-law turns a family gathering into a forum on your weight or outfit, calmly assert yourself, saying only these words: "No more comments on my appearance, please." Be prepared for her to insist you're crazy, oversensitive, and unfairly accusing her. This is bait. Do not take it. Getting into any sort of debate allows her to cast you as neurotic and mean and cast herself as the victim.
Be prepared for her to "forget" and attack you again. Simply reiterate your mantra, in a cool, calm voice: "No more comments on my appearance, please." You'll shut her up without looking like the bad guy, but you'll both know what you really mean: "Inside me, there's a skinny person longing to get out, shove a Tide Pod and load of socks in your mouth, and put your head on spin."
For pages and pages of "science-help" from me, buy my latest book, "Unf*ckology: A Field Guide to Living with Guts and Confidence." It lays out the PROCESS of transforming to live w/confidence.








100% all of this.
I married into a family where women (especially in my MIL's generation) critique each other's appearances and fashion choices. It's just what they do. They see nothing wrong with it.
They're being direct with you. So be direct with them. Amy's phrasing is great. I've also used, "Well I bought this dress, so obviously I like it."
Oh, and your spouse needs to speak up, too, if he sees your SIL doing this. You might not be able to tell her to "shut up," but he can.
My friend has a very critical Russian MIL. When she lays in, her husband jumps to my friend's defense by saying, "Mom, shut the f*ck up" in Russian.
sofar at May 4, 2020 9:39 AM
Changing the way you react is highly underrated as a technique for this kind of nastiness.
Kate at May 6, 2020 9:17 PM
I find snide remarks come mostly from women in a maternal role... mothers and aunts, who think it's their job to keep improving you long after you've grown up, or MILs who think it is their job to train you to be the perfect wife.
I don't see this at all from age peers.
NicoleK at May 9, 2020 11:59 AM
OP: these people are cads and you definitely should insist they treat your feelings with respect.
However, going by your examples, it reads to me that the comments aren't so much about your body, but that you might not be terrific at dressing it flatteringly. Few of us are.
Perhaps there's a friend who has NOT been boorish to you---maybe someone whose wardrobe you admire---from whom you could seek clothing advice....rewarding someone who has supported you, rather than giving the other bozos the satisfaction.
Treadwell at May 23, 2020 3:10 PM
Leave a comment