Waking The Dad
My boyfriend and I recently discussed having children. I want them, but he's a little on the fence. He says he needs to be in a better financial place before thinking about kids. I wonder whether that's just an excuse to put off the topic indefinitely.
--Worried
Children bring their parents a lot of joy -- and it helps to remember that as you're jazzwalking to the office so you can put your gas money toward your kid's fourth round of dental work.
Children are seriously expensive, so maybe your boyfriend just feels a serious sense of responsibility to support the little buggers while being unsure of exactly how many million bajillions that could take. Economist Daniel Ellsberg observed that we humans are deeply disturbed by ambiguity -- a lack of information about how things could turn out. Some people are so ambiguity-averse (aka uncertainty-averse) they'll opt for an immediate sure loss over the possibility of a future gain. It's why people sometimes sabotage a new relationship: They can't stand not knowing whether the thing'll tank, so they blow it up themselves.
To figure out where your boyfriend really stands, replace the ambiguity with information. Together, add up the costs of having kids (factoring in health care, emergencies, grad school, rehab, etc.). From that, project the date of his financial readiness. You might also ask him about any fears he has about having kids. Discussing them might shrink them -- or make it clear that he isn't daddy material and that you should start looking for a man who is. Though retailers allow you to return many items, even if they're slightly used, maternity wards don't work like that: "Excuse me, Nurse...these three kids turned out to be unexpectedly loud, sticky, and expensive, but I don't see your return policy on the receipts."
"Sir, those are birth certificates."
For pages and pages of "science-help" from me, buy my latest book, "Unf*ckology: A Field Guide to Living with Guts and Confidence." It lays out the PROCESS of transforming to live w/confidence.








Guys who want kids know they want kids. As it stands, your boyfriend does not.
Don't do the thing so many women do where they hear what they want to hear and not what is being said.
Maybe someday he will change his mind, but right now, no, he does not want kids.
NicoleK at May 4, 2020 5:21 AM
"My boyfriend and I recently discussed having children. "
Um, no. Marriage first, kids later.
iowaan at May 5, 2020 9:58 AM
I assumed this was a "Would you like to have kids some day" conversation, not, "Shall we make a baby this month?"
NicoleK at May 5, 2020 12:00 PM
NicoleK is correct. Boyfriend's statement about needing to be in a better place financially is not a statement of concern. It's a rationalization. Or, to be more male-specific, it's a strategic move to fight the battle on turf he can easily defend (finances) and off more difficult-to-defend territory (his personal preference on not wanting kids period). This is not part of a back-and-forth dialog. It's someone stating something as unambiguously as he can, without provoking a confrontation or forcing Girlfriend to leave.
the gift at May 5, 2020 2:17 PM
I think there's too much context missing for any of the conclusions offered to be supportable. Is he a college student majoring in literature, unsure if he'll be employable, or a lawyer worried he won't make partner?
Let's face it, most of the commenters here can point to a lot of people they would prefer had been more concerned about their ability to feed what the breed.
bw1 at May 10, 2020 9:29 AM
The college student and lawyer will have set goals, "When I get tenure" or "When I make partner". They'll be clear. If kids are a life goal, they will have made a plan for it.
NicoleK at May 11, 2020 10:17 AM
How old are these people? How long have they been dating? Obviously they aren't married, so she might be putting the cart before the horse to talk about children.
It's also possible they may not be on the same page about timeline: She could be vetting out what type of parent he may be "some day," or whether he wants kids at all. He may be thinking she wants to have kids right away, and he's not at a place where he's ready.
Mort at May 28, 2020 10:07 AM
Leave a comment