"When Bread Is Assured, Circuses Fill Men's Minds"
Dalrymple on snobbery, the World Cup, how things have changed, and what it says about our societies:
In 1998, the French team won the World Cup and there was a burst of national euphoria as a result. The team of 1998 was composed of blancs, beurs, noirs - that is to say, whites, Arabs, blacks - and this was taken, briefly, as evidence of the success of France as a multicultural and multiethnic society. Huge crowds greeted the successful team as it paraded in the modern equivalent of a Roman triumph. Preposterous triviality could go no further.
Twelve years later, when the French team lost miserably in the same competition, the opposite sentiments were widely expressed, at least in the newspapers and on the air. The team was now predominantly black and Arab; anyone who knew France only through its national football team would place the country somewhere between North and Equatorial Africa. One prominent white in the team, a spectacularly ugly and thuggish-looking man, so ill-educated that he could barely string a few words together, let alone a sentence, in his native language, had converted to Islam. Another white in the squad, a blonde Breton who was notably better-educated than his colleagues, had to be excluded from the team because none of the others would co-operate with or pass the ball to him.
When the Marseillaise was played before a match started in which the French were to play, the team refused to sing it or accord it any respect. While it is perfectly normal for many Frenchmen not to know all the words - which is probably as well, since they are horribly bloodthirsty, and include the hope that the impure blood of aristocrats may irrigate the ploughed furrows of the peasantry - almost all know at least the first four lines. The players appeared to be expressing their disdain for the country they supposedly represented and that had enabled them to become multi-millionaires by the age of 20. At the root of their resentment would not be injustice, but remembered slights, real or imagined.
...But what really mattered to people in France was victory or defeat in the sporting contest, not the state of society. Football was more important to them than anything else, and a victory - or at any rate, a more dignified defeat - would have anaesthetised their thoughts about the country's social problems.
It seems to me very odd, and not at all reassuring, that a country such as France, with a practically unrivalled history of achievement in all the major fields of human endeavour, should have been precipitated into an orgy of self-examination by something as trivial as a failure in a football competition, when it is utterly indifferent to questions of incomparably greater importance: for example, why it is completely incapable, after a continuous and millennial history of wonderful architecture, of erecting a decent building, one that is not an eyesore? (It is not alone in this, of course.) I have never seen this question so much as raised, let alone answered, though I do not think any reasonably alert person could drive through France without asking himself it....The glory and civilisation of France was thus reduced to eleven men on a field successfully, and admittedly with great skill, kicking a ball about. Zidane, incidentally, was a player of Maghrebian descent, the great hero of the 1998 competition and a man who looks considerably more intelligent than any of the players today; he blotted his copybook slightly when he head-butted another player, an act that he explained by saying that you can take a boy out of a slum, but you can't take a slum out of a boy.
Thanks, Crid







Think carefully about persons, as well as nations, for whom a "hero" is someone who plays with a ball.
Radwaste at July 12, 2010 2:13 AM
I don't think the misplaced hero status is the story here. The misplaced hero syndrome is, likely, something that is older than the Circus Maximus. The story is the conspicuous lack of pride/conspicuous show of near disdain in the nation the players are representing. The story is how a society allows this to happen under the likely phony cry of 'equality and multiculturalism'. In the larger context, this is connected to the black panther party issue happening in the U.S. (among others). The ultra liberal mindset is: if you have the right skin color, certain behaviors at best will be overlooked at worst is acceptable. Since the ultra liberals control much of the media (meaning they have quite a bit of control over the direction of national conversation), this type of bad behavior will continue largely unabated.
I don't think -- and I hope I am not wrong -- the U.S. would tolerate this from a national team. While many media outlets would not cover the story (for reasons noted above), I believe many still would (certainly those liars and politically slanted racist hacks at Fox). And that is just one more reason why Obama should take his European utopia ideas to somewhere else (like Europe).
TW at July 12, 2010 3:29 AM
This Dalrymple guy is absolutely right, even though he's talking about the wrong sport. Here's what he meant to say:
"Dear Madame and Mr Reader -- We live in troubling times. When bread is assured, circus- sized peanuts fill men's minds. And the barbarians are knocking at the gate...the staring gate, that is. After all, what sport is associated with the ancient tradition of the circus? That's right, Ricky Bobby, it's the chariot race. And guess where the majority of these cretin race fans come from? Indiana, that's where. The End. "
Jason S. at July 12, 2010 10:41 AM
The writer missed to mention that the technical director of the French team, Raymond Domenech, based his selection of the players on astrology. For instance, the team could not have more than three players who were born on July; or nobody under the sign of Capricorn was allowed to play, and such crap. Astrology being the main factor for the player selection, one can only imagine how "good" he was on training and tactics as well.
Therefore, the failure of the French team goes far deeper than the mere nationality of the players.
Radwaste said: "Think carefully about persons, as well as nations, for whom a "hero" is someone who plays with a ball."
To the French people, and to many more in the whole world, soccer is the national sport, just as football, baseball of volleyball are to the Americans. I wonder how many Americans consider Magic Johnson a "hero", but I don't think that ALL of you actually think so. My point: there's no need to generalize a whole country and mock its people as if all of them were ignorant fanatics, being that every country, including yours, have a number of them. Just not *everyone*.
Mexicanita at July 12, 2010 10:51 AM
Leave a comment