Poor Woman's Prozac
It just might be semen. From Jesse Bering's SciAm column:
Given these ingredients--and this is just a small sample of the mind-altering "drugs" found in human semen--Gallup and Burch, along with psychologist Steven Platek, now at the University of Liverpool, hypothesized that women having unprotected sex should be less depressed than suitable control participants. To investigate whether semen has antidepressant effects, the authors rounded up 293 college females from the SUNY-Albany campus, who agreed to fill out an anonymous, written questionnaire about various aspects of their sexual behavior. Recent sexual activity without condoms was used as an indirect measure of seminal plasma circulating in the woman's body. Each participant also completed the Beck Depression Inventory, a commonly used clinical measure of depressive symptoms.The most significant findings from this 2002 study, published with criminally modest fanfare in the Archives of Sexual Behavior , were these: even after adjusting for frequency of sexual intercourse, women who engaged in sex and "never" used condoms showed significantly fewer depressive symptoms than did those who "usually" or "always" used condoms. Importantly, these chronically condomless, sexually active women also evidenced fewer depressive symptoms than did those who abstained from sex altogether. By contrast, sexually active women, even really promiscuous ones, who used condoms were just as depressed as those practicing total abstinence. In other words, it's not just that women who are having sex are simply happier, but instead happiness appears to be a function of the ambient seminal fluid pulsing through one's veins.
And it gets better. A smaller percentage (4.5 percent) of the sexually active women who "never" used condoms were less likely to have attempted suicide than were those who "sometimes" (7.4 percent) and "usually" (28.9 percent) and "always" (13.2 percent) used condoms.
Relax, settle down, take a deep breath--I know what you're thinking. This is a correlational study and there are scores of possible confounds, both those that the authors anticipated and controlled for in this study design (by all means read the actual article for more details--but please do note that these between-group differences in depression panned out even after controlling for the use of oral contraceptives, days since last sex, frequency of sex and duration of the relationship with the male partner) and probably some that you can come up with on your own.
Birth control pills also affect who a woman is attracted to. Now, I'm not a doctor (note "The Advice Goddess" above), but from what I've read, unless you go psycho without them and take them for mood regulation, it's probably not a good idea to take them! Best birth control in my estimation is probably the Copper-7 IUD. No hormones, no barriers.







Oh, the bad jokes just waiting to be made!
The results are interesting, but as yet pretty meaningless. This is a sample of only 293 women, where the participants must voluntarily answer very intimite questions. Getting accurate results out of this - especially when there are so many possible confounding factors - is essentially impossible.
At best, this may justify a genuine double-blind study. Just don't tell the women the source of what may be in the pills...
bradley13 at September 30, 2010 3:23 AM
"Just don't tell the women the source of what may be in the pills"...well, does it work if you take it orally? I'd guess "no", because otherwise, various forms of oral ingestion would be messing up the strong correlations here...
david foster at September 30, 2010 6:28 AM
I highly recommend the Essure implants made by Conceptus. The procedure is quick and simple, nonsurgical, and 30 days later you never have to mess with birth control again. I got mine when I was 34 and went to a job interview the next day.
http://essure.com/Home/Understanding/WhatisEssure/tabid/55/Default.aspx?gclid=CKeP_52jr6QCFZQz5wodrhVa1Q
Pirate Jo at September 30, 2010 6:39 AM
I got Mirena, but it's not for everyone. The insertion was so painful that I'm not sure I'd do it again if I had to. I'm totally happy with it now, though.
MonicaP at September 30, 2010 7:15 AM
^ Argggggg matey! There be some pirate spam above ye disguised as a comment!
This study made me laugh. All I can say is CHEERS!
Rosemary444 at September 30, 2010 7:21 AM
"an extended study on more than 700 women has backed up these findings"
From a BBC report on the original study:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/2067223.stm
"Semen makes women happy" :)
Martin at September 30, 2010 9:05 AM
This study made me laugh. All I can say is CHEERS!
Posted by: Rosemary444 at September 30, 2010 7:21
eh? If you read through, this is not just one study or one thing...
The fallout of all this seems like it's far reaching... and you'd think thatit would be the talk of all the morning talkies, but after all these years... silence.
I would suspect that it has something to do with the part where there is a big enough problem getting people to do birth control, before you start telling them that there is a down side to barrier methods.
But, it might be a big deal if the reasons why there is a certain amount of drift between the genders has to do with our blocking biology from working...
OTOH, a savvy entrepeneur might want to bottle the ingredients to get around barrier methods. Heh, if I was the KY company, I'd be spending a lot of R&D to figure it out.
SwissArmyD at September 30, 2010 9:47 AM
I got Essure. Which now means I have to have a in-hospital hydrothermal endometrial ablation instead of the 90 second in-office electric one. Which is a pain, but otherwise Essure is GREAT!!!
momof4 at September 30, 2010 10:20 AM
Didn't the phrase "Oh, ick!" cross anyone's mind as he or she was reading this? Just asking...
Old RPM Daddy at September 30, 2010 10:22 AM
Also, "poor" has nothing to do with it. Why buy Prozac when I can get semen for free? I'm just frugal!
MonicaP at September 30, 2010 10:22 AM
"I got Mirena, but it's not for everyone."
Yeah, according to their commercials you have to be a morally pure June Cleaver for a decade first. I always like the Yaz ads for the chocolatini set, except their sound dubbing is always off and people don't actually verbalize the 6 point font disclaimer in a conversation.
And swiss: you mean ANOTHER downside to barrier methods.
smurfy at September 30, 2010 12:22 PM
Ex-Psycho here with PERFECT skin thanks to yaz
ppen at September 30, 2010 12:28 PM
This explains why homosexuals are referred to as "gay".
-or-
Nurse, this woman is severely depressed. Get Peter North in here immediately!
eric
at September 30, 2010 12:39 PM
I'm 26, and have had a copper iud for over 3 years. I agree that it is by far the best birth control and I tried so many in the 7 years before I got the iud. Depo shot, 6 different bc pills, and the patch.
The only downside to the IUD is finding a doctor to give you one if you are young and childless, because it can dislodge and end up messing up your fertility, which I guess isn't as big of a deal to women who have already had a child... That's the basic response I received. I found one, paid $500 for 10 years of birth control, then received a check for $480 back after insurance picked up the tab (aetna super high deductible plan).
My only real complaint is that now that there are no hormones in my system, I have my REAL period, which is 6-7 days instead of 3-4 and light. But, I have only had 1 migraine in 3 years instead of 20+ in the year before I got the iud.
Casey at September 30, 2010 12:55 PM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2010/09/30/poor_womans_pro.html#comment-1760482">comment from CaseyHave copper myself, and sorry boys, but Casey, if you want to minimize periods, try sauteeing a big clump of fresh Italian parsley daily and eating it. Daily. Lots of butter, shrink the parsley down until it's small and a little crunchy (I do it on high heat), and you should see a difference in...I dunno...maybe a month or so.
Amy Alkon
at September 30, 2010 1:14 PM
I suspect that eating a big clump of fresh-cooked parsley may improve the semen's, uh, qualities as well. Certainly it would be a better choice than asparagus.
Steve H at September 30, 2010 2:07 PM
Before we were married, my wife was on birth control pills due to painful periods.
We have since had infertility issues that seem to have include an immune-compatibility element.
Impossible to know anything, but maybe if she hadn't been on the pills she would have dumped me as genetically unsuitable.
Anon at September 30, 2010 2:34 PM
Parsley? Never heard of that helping but I'll look into it and start stocking up on parsley! I'm about to close on my first house and if it works, I'll be planting some. Do you know how it helps? Just curious! I'm going to google it now.
Casey at September 30, 2010 4:17 PM
OK... maybe it's because I came of age in the 90s... but this article freaks me out. CONDOMS people, CONDOMS! Preferably with foam. You know, the little rubber things we put on bananas during safe sex workshops in High School. The little packets in the basket in the nurse's office.
Nothing else can protect you from STDs, except chastity (which I'm defining as abstinence or sex with only one partner who has already been tested clean for everything).
Think about how depressed you will be if you get an STD.
I think we need to take account of the risks vs benefits of behavior.
NicoleK at October 1, 2010 12:57 PM
I trieda Paraguard copper IUD several years ago and my body rejected it. Despite it being confirmed properly seated my uterus did it's best to get rid of the foreign object. I had it for about two weeks after paying $500 to get it. I can't take hormonal birth control of any form because of an autoimmune clotting disorder so instead have practiced NFP/FAM for birth control for years with no issue. And before somebody says it, it is not thr rhythm method. It involves taking your basal body temperature every morning, tracking your cervix and cervical mucus. It's quite easy to pinpoint when you are fertile and then confirm when you've ovulated with your temperature. I realize thus method isn't for everyone.
I'm very againt Essure because the metal in the coils contains nickel, which is not disclosed information. They also very often migrate at some point even after they've been confirmed properly seated on HSG. This leads to very painful cramping, bleeding, and life threatening injuries with uterine perforation. There is a class action lawsuit in process of being filed against it right now and an invetigation into pulling it from the market. There is a similar procedure out with a non-metal implant called Adiana that sounds much safer but it's still cery new.
BunnyGirl at October 1, 2010 3:09 PM
"OK... maybe it's because I came of age in the 90s... but this article freaks me out. CONDOMS people, CONDOMS! Preferably with foam. You know, the little rubber things we put on bananas during safe sex workshops in High School. The little packets in the basket in the nurse's office.
Nothing else can protect you from STDs, except chastity (which I'm defining as abstinence or sex with only one partner who has already been tested clean for everything).
Think about how depressed you will be if you get an STD.
I think we need to take account of the risks vs benefits of behavior."
I think we need to consider the risks vs the benefits too but it is still very possible to get an STD while using condoms. I have a family member who acquired one while using a condom diligently, The AIDS panic of the 80's and 90's made condoms sound like the solution to everything but in reality they are not nearly as good as knowing the sexual history of your partner and having a loving trusting relationship since most STDs can be transmitted orally as well as vaginally. Condoms are certainly a good idea if you are the type of person who engages in casual hookups but they are not really all that effective at preventing either pregnancy or disease.
Isabel1130 at October 1, 2010 5:37 PM
Yes of course it is still possible, but the risk is greatly reduced. Which of course doesn't help you if you're the statistic...
NicoleK at October 3, 2010 7:31 AM
Well, like I said elsewhere on this topic, I know I feel better after a good rogering! :P
As for condoms, HPV is one STD that's easy to catch in spite of condom use, since it only requires a little skin to skin contact. A good percentage of people have it and are unaware they have it. The vaccine protects against two of the worst strains (the ones most commonly associated with cervical cancer), but there are loads more out there and no one wants genital warts, even if it's relatively harmless.
Thag Jones at October 4, 2010 6:12 AM
If there is a class action lawsuit against Essure I would surely love to know what lawyer. Please e-mail me with information. I am bankrupt and now diabettic from complications and weight gain after having two surgeries to fix my uterus and then remove it after one migrated up into my upper left corner of my uterus, punctured the uterus and had I not had a carring boyfriend at the time I could have ended up dead because the doctors tried to tell me it was all in my head for 3 months, which would have been easy for them to sweep me under the carpet because I got suicidal after my divorce to whom I lost my daughter because I was already on disability for Rheumatoid Arthritis. Oh I also had 2 IUD's and even though one of those migrated up and got lodged in the side of my uterus at least I knew It was missing due to the string being gone, So I would still say that the IUD's are safer than Essure and I actually think the copper on the IUD I used helped my Rheumatoid Arthritis some. So it was worth the $500.00 for 6yrs of BC. I could never take the pill, I had morning sickness every time I tried to take it for the whole 1st month or more, then I would give up because it was 24/7 morningsickness. YUK>
Still paying bills and mad. Just found out I have diabettes two months ago and angry as heck, still have to much scar tissue in my belly to exersize now too and increased back pain daily. Pain clinics are not helping and my doctor refuses to refill my vicodin. Don't know what to do, my boyfriend/now husband waits on me hand and foot the poor thing. I'm hot under the collar now. Please e-mail me.
vikinglady at November 22, 2010 5:32 PM
I am also looking to see if any has a class action law suit againist EESURE... I taste metal all he time.. I have back pain and stomach pain.. Leg cramps all the time. Also now I have been to the doctor and have a thing called Cervicitis which it can be caused be STD's but I dont have any and neither does my husband of 10 years... But it can also be cause by injury to the cervix from a foreign object inserted in the vagina, from birth control devices such as the cervical cap or a diaphragm... Which EESURE is a foreign object and birth conrol.. So I am all messed up... So please let me know something please... My email is peaches244foru at yahoo . com thanks again Tasha
Tasha at April 1, 2011 10:59 AM
I dont know why anyone would recommend the Essure!! I had the procedure done after my 3rd child. did what I was suppost to do, as far as brth control for 3 months till the scar tissue formed around the coils. Went back in 3 months to get check to make sure my tubes were sealed. And after the test they said I was good to go! tubes sealed! I got pregnant a year later. My doctor recommended it and I guess Its my fault for not researching it better.
April Hicks at September 19, 2011 9:38 PM
Leave a comment