Why Videotape The Savage Murder Of A Little Jewish Girl?
Caroline Glick writes about the bigger implications of the murder, by jihadist Mohamed Merah, of the three little French-Jewish schoolchildren and the young rabbi:
Why did he take the trouble of strapping a video camera to his neck and filming himself chasing eight-year-old Miriam Monsonego through the school courtyard and shooting her three times in the head? Why did he document his execution of Rabbi Jonathan Sandler and his two little boys, three-year-old Gavriel and six-year-old Aryeh?The first answer is because Merah took pride in killing Jewish children. Beyond that, he was certain that millions of people would be heartened by his crime. By watching him shoot the life out of Jewish children, they would be inspired to repeat his actions elsewhere.
And he was surely correct.
Millions of people have watched the 2002 video of Daniel Pearl being decapitated. Similar decapitation videos of Western hostages in Iraq and elsewhere have also become runaway Internet sensations.
Led by Youssef Fofana, the Muslim gang in France that kidnapped and tortured Ilan Halimi to death in 2006 also took pictures of their handiwork. Their photographs were clearly imitations of the photos that Pearl's killers took of him before they chopped his head off.
The pride that jihadist murderers take in their crimes is not merely manifested in their camera work. US Army Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan, who massacred 13 US servicemen at Fort Hood in 2009, showed obvious pride in his dedication to jihad. Hassan gave a presentation to his colleagues justifying jihad. He carried business cards in which he identified himself as an "SOA," a soldier of Allah.
Similarly, Naveed Haq, the American Muslim who carried out the attack at the Seattle Jewish Federation building in 2006, murdering one woman and wounding another five, bragged to his mother and friend about his crime in monitored telephone calls from jail. Haq boasted that he was "a jihadi" and that his victims deserved to die because they were "Israeli collaborators."
The exhibitionism common to all the men's behavior makes it obvious that that their attacks were not the random actions of isolated crazy people or lone extremists. All of these killers were certain that they were part of a global movement that seeks the annihilation of the Jews, the subjugation of the Western world and the supremacy of jihadist Islam. And they were convinced that their actions served the interests of this movement and that they would be viewed as heroes by millions of their fellow Muslims for their killing of innocents.
More in the New York Post and way more at CIFwatch. And Islam's commands to commit violence here:
Speaking of peace and love may win over the ignorant, but when every twelfth verse of Islam's holiest book either speaks to Allah's hatred for non-Muslims or calls for their death, forced conversion, or subjugation, it's little wonder that sympathy for terrorism runs as deeply as it does in the broader community - even if most Muslims personally prefer not to interpret their religion in this way.
Although scholars like Ibn Khaldun, one of Islam's most respected philosophers, understood that "the holy war is a religious duty, because of the universalism of the Muslim mission and (the obligation to) convert everybody to Islam either by persuasion or by force", many other Muslims are either unaware or willfully ignorant of the Quran's near absence of verses that preach universal non-violence. Their understanding of Islam comes from what they are taught by others. In the West, it is typical for believers to think that their religion must be like Christianity - preaching the New Testament virtues of peace, love, and tolerance - because Muslims are taught that Islam is supposed to be superior in every way. They are somewhat surprised and embarrassed to learn that the evidence of the Quran and the bloody history of Islam are very much in contradiction to this.
Others simply accept the violence. In 1991, a Palestinian couple in America was convicted of stabbing their daughter to death for being too Westernized. A family friend came to their defense, excoriating the jury for not understanding the "culture", claiming that the father was merely following "the religion" and saying that the couple had to "discipline their daughter or lose respect." (source). In 2011, unrepentant Palestinian terrorists, responsible for the brutal murders of civilians, women and children explicitly in the name of Allah were treated to a luxurious "holy pilgrimage" to Mecca by the Saudi king - without a single Muslim voice raised in protest.







But Trayvon is more important.
Radwaste at March 24, 2012 3:08 AM
Caroline Glick's piece is outstanding.
Donald Douglas at March 24, 2012 8:19 AM
And one of our soldiers a week ago went on a murder spree killing 16 innocent civillians, including 11 Muslim sleeping children.
And Trayvon is important. Had the roles been reversed, the young black kid would no doubt be charged with murder, as an adult.
I'm not trying to be a liberal pain in the ass, but we can't cherry pick justice. These are all examples of senseless tragedy.
Eric at March 24, 2012 8:45 AM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2012/03/24/why_videotape_t.html#comment-3095704">comment from EricHere's the difference, Eric: We don't have a mandate, as there are many mandates in the Quran, to do these things. We don't have the non-Muslim version of imams standing up before their "flock" commanding them to convert or kill the infidel. We don't teach our children, as Palestinians and other Muslims do, that Jews are apes and pigs and that slaughtering them is good. There will always be horrible people who murder -- but Islam's calls to murder are at the root of this man's horrible slaughter...chasing an 8-year-old child down and shooting her point-blank to the head.
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2012 8:50 AM
And that soldier was an anomaly while the disgusting fucks that want to kill Jewish folk in the name of Islam are so common that nobody raises an eyebrow. Eric, take your moral equivalence and shove it up your ass.
Darin Johnson at March 24, 2012 9:05 AM
I agree with you on those points...
Eric at March 24, 2012 9:07 AM
There is no question of what happened here. I cry everytime I see Miriam's picture. Folks it is really necessary to figure out how to cull the herd of man.
Dave B at March 24, 2012 10:03 AM
This is probably going to be the most religious century in human history. religion is what a generation or two of hillbillies turn to when their village gets brought into a larger economic and political framework. You have to get used to this... you can't tell people to ignore religion just because you want them to and thiNk it would be better for them.
The United States is the most religious country in the world, but this is where you want to live, right?
religion ain't the problem. primitivism and disconnectedness are the problems.
writing on a iPad at frys electronics. Kinda slow and clumsy
crid at March 24, 2012 10:05 AM
Caroline Glick's piece is a great bit of writing, but there's one point she's missing:
"Their photographs were clearly imitations of the photos that Pearl's killers took of him before they chopped his head off"
That's true, but the likes of Mohamed Merah aren't just copying other jihadis. They are following the example of the original Mohamed. For just one example, in 627 the Qurayzah, a tribe of Jewish Arabs, surrendered after the Muslim conquest of Medina. Mohamed ordered all the men to be slaughtered in front of their families, and the women & children to be raped and sold into slavery. He eagerly participated himself, and then he received a revelation from Allah praising his actions, which is now Verse 33:26 of the Koran:
"And those of the People of the Book who aided them - Allah did take them down from their strongholds and cast terror into their hearts. (So that) some ye slew, and some ye made prisoners"
Mohamed didn't have cameras or the internet in the seventh century, but that never stopped him, and Mohamed Merah was following his example in word and in deed. That fact ought to be addressed somehow. Robert Bales is at least a nominal Christian, but he won't be able to find any justification or praise for his actions in the Gospel or the actions of Christ.
Martin at March 24, 2012 10:40 AM
Compelling writing from you and Caroline Glick. Miriam's murder exemplifies the unique and awful purpose of Islamofascism.
Amy L at March 24, 2012 11:21 AM
The soldier in Afghanistan had been on multiple tours of duty--the French guy sat in his apartment, on the dole, watching snuff films. There's a big difference. While the solider may or may not have PTSD or may or may not be just a violent asshole--Merah is just a violent wacko, easily swayed by imans preaching death to infidels. He had not personally suffered any violence against himself. The two cases are not remotely similar.
KateC at March 24, 2012 12:17 PM
I'm with you Eric, murdered kids are murdered kids. It's all heart-breaking.
Sam at March 24, 2012 12:41 PM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2012/03/24/why_videotape_t.html#comment-3096296">comment from KateCYes, in the end, a murdered child is a murdered child, but KateC is exactly right. Read my comment above on how the Quran and Islam command such violence of Muslims -- which, obviously, isn't to say that all Muslims follow such commands.
Many Muslims have no idea what is in the Quran, or, for example that there is the Mecca portion of the Quran and the later Medina Quran (the evil, convert or slaughter the infidel and take their homes and possessions stuff). After Mohammed got some power, he showed himself to be a mass-murdering, murder-commanding barbarian. The later passages commanding Muslim violence against the rest of us abrogate -- dismiss -- the earlier more peacie-weacie passages.
Again, I'm an atheist, but I can get behind Jesus' "turn the other cheek" and "feed the poor." Islam's "Kill people who don't believe in Allah"? No.
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2012 1:18 PM
"While the solider may or may not have PTSD or may or may not be just a violent asshole--Merah is just a violent wacko, easily swayed by imans preaching death to infidels."
Robert Bales is the final product of US culture, which views the Muslims as subhuman or inferior.
Do you remember the picture of Marines, who were pissing on the dead Taliban?
If we don't look at Muslims as humans either dead or alive, Osama Bin Laden is going to finally succeed in pushing all of us back to "primitive and disconnected" period.
In a perfect world, Robert Bales will be handed over to Afghan government to be tried for the crimes he may or may not have committed. And he should the face the parents of those slain children in the Afghan court not US court.
At this point, he has a very good shot at escaping any punishment at all for killing innocent children by pleading insanity.
chang at March 24, 2012 1:29 PM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2012/03/24/why_videotape_t.html#comment-3096370">comment from changRobert Bales is the final product of US culture, which views the Muslims as subhuman or inferior.
Bullshit. I'm a product of US culture and I don't view any human as "subhuman" or "inferior." I think Islam is an evil-promoting religion -- commanding the violent death or conversion of non-Muslims.
Furthermore, Americans want to believe that any religious belief system is okay. If there's an overweening belief it's that. I believed and wanted to believe that about Islam until I started reading and found out that it is actually not a religion but an evil totalitarian system masquerading as a religion.
Oh, and I don't use the word "evil" lightly. A religion that commands people to slaughter those who believe differently, which Islam does, is very fucking evil.
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2012 1:53 PM
"Do you remember the picture of Marines, who were pissing on the dead Taliban?"
Yeah, that's comparable to killing children.
Dave B at March 24, 2012 3:02 PM
Acctually chang, Bales is the end result of military culture which reenforced the idea that ANY enemy is sub human - because if they are human you feel guilty for trying to shoot them coupled with political indifference for soldiers needs and health
You want someone to blame for Bales' victims? Blame Obama for not ending the wars as promised, blame Bush for firing Shenski for giving an honest estimate of the troops needed to do the job, blame congress as it is there job and not the presidents to declare war.
If Bales is guilty our 537 federal represenitives are even more so
lujlp at March 24, 2012 3:10 PM
Chang, you are an ignorant anti-american slut. To say that America is anti-muslim is just so ignorant. I wish we were, I wish we would declare this war to be a war on Islam, instead we go out of our way to grisly grannies at airports. I hope you and your loved ones feel the pain of the next 9-11.
ronc at March 24, 2012 3:30 PM
Again, I'm an atheist, but I can get behind Jesus' "turn the other cheek" and "feed the poor." Islam's "Kill people who don't believe in Allah"? No.
Yes, Jesus was different than Muhammed. Muhammed was a warrior; Jesus was not. Islamic extremists are more rabid, and more violent, than Christian extremists.
But Islam doesn't have a patent on the "kill people who don't believe thing." After all, according to the Bible, the God of Christians wiped out not just all people but "every living substance" (except for Noah & his critters) simply because he was pissed off that mankind was "wicked."
JD at March 24, 2012 3:38 PM
> In a perfect world, Robert Bales will be
> handed over to Afghan government to be
> tried for the crimes he may or may not have
> committed.
How old are you? Young people love to dream of the "perfect" planet.
> Robert Bales is the final product of US culture
You're more recent than he is, aren't you?
Crid at March 24, 2012 4:11 PM
"But Islam doesn't have a patent on the "kill people who don't believe thing." After all, according to the Bible, the God of Christians wiped out not just all people but "every living substance" (except for Noah & his critters) simply because he was pissed off that mankind was "wicked."
Dude, do you really mean to compare the reality of today with a story book? Shall we just leave it at let God and Allah do the killing personally and everyone else stay out of it.
Dave B at March 24, 2012 4:20 PM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2012/03/24/why_videotape_t.html#comment-3096875">comment from Dave BThe bible is allegory and believed to be a historical document. Muslims are told that the Quran is to be taken literally and unquestioningly as the word of Allah. If you wonder why there are so many Jews who are Nobel laureates -- way, way, way beyond their percentage of the population -- and why there are only a handful of Muslim ones, it could be because Muslims are taught not to question the "science" in the Quran.
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2012 5:58 PM
"At this point, he has a very good shot at escaping any punishment at all for killing innocent children by pleading insanity."
Just say it, chang: you want the man to die, not "justice". The idea that he gets a trial at all over there is pure naiveté.
Radwaste at March 24, 2012 6:17 PM
"Just say it, chang: you want the man to die, not "justice". The idea that he gets a trial at all over there is pure naiveté."
Fine.
Would you please volunteer to inform this man that Robert Bales was found innocent by the bored California jurors, who were eager to watch the final minutes of NCAA finals?
http://www.rawa.org/temp/runews/2012/03/14/the-price-of-a-lifeo-in-afghanistan-it-s-as-little-as-210.phtml
chang at March 24, 2012 7:41 PM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2012/03/24/why_videotape_t.html#comment-3097248">comment from changWould you please volunteer to inform this man that Robert Bales was found innocent by the bored California jurors, who were eager to watch the final minutes of NCAA finals?
Huh?
Are you entirely clueless about the military and a military court-martial?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Courts-martial_in_the_United_States
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2012 7:58 PM
Lujlp says -
Acctually chang, Bales is the end result of military culture which reenforced the idea that ANY enemy is sub human - because if they are human you feel guilty for trying to shoot them coupled with political indifference for soldiers needs and health
Cut the bullshit, which is made more insulting by the "political indifference for soldiers needs and health" bone thrown in. I am a soldier, among soldiers who have never done anything like what Bales did, and have never been taught, come to regard or know anyone who has been taught or come to regard what he did or anything like it as any better than murder.Take your "damaged combat vet made crazy by what he has seen and done" hollywood cliches and stuff them up your ass. If Bales did what he is accused of doing it is for the same reason rapists rape and thieves steal. Thats who and what they are. I have seen your writing before Lujlp and I seriously doubt you would tolerate anyone blaming a rape on "rape culture" or "male conditioning." You would rightly call it the act of a criminal. So it is with Bales.
As for Trayvon, tragic yes. This guy Zimmerman sounds like a piece of work and I can't imagine how the PD down there breathes or chews their food with their heads that far up their asses. At the same time, I cant help but notice that 49 deaths over St Patricks day weekend on Chicagos South side (where our dear leaderwas a community activist) is apparently business as usual - no outcry for them. Absolute crickets from the Black Outrage Industry. They were killed by blacks. Now, one kid killed by a white guy (actually hispanic, but hey - Al and Jesse gotta eat) merits outrage all the way up to the President. Between the outrage over Trayvon, and the silence of the black community over the slaughter of blacks by other blacks, I have to wonder if all anybody is really upset about is that a white person killed a black person - not that a black person was killed. And while we are discussing selective, politically motivated outrage -
Trayvon could have been your son, Barack?
Allen Goin could have been mine. Can we expect a comment on him some time soon?
http://www.theblaze.com/stories/you-get-what-you-deserve-white-boy-13-year-old-set-on-fire-in-horrific-racially-charged-attack/
The WolfMan at March 24, 2012 8:33 PM
Amen wolfman
ronc at March 24, 2012 8:57 PM
Just to remind everyone, Chang is our resident Stalinist. As far as he's concerned, the only mistake Stalin, Hitler, Mao, and Pol Pot made is that they didn't go far enough.
"At the same time, I cant help but notice that 49 deaths over St Patricks day weekend on Chicagos South side..."
Yeah, the lesson here for young black men is: Make sure you get murdered by someone who looks white. Otherwise, your life has no value.
Cousin Dave at March 24, 2012 9:30 PM
Otherwise, your life has no value...to Al Sharpton, Obama, or other professional race-baiters.
Martin at March 24, 2012 11:11 PM
Wolfman, blow me. I'm a vet as well. Note I said military culture, not US military culture.
If your enenmy is the emotion equivelent of your kids you wont fire and will get your squadmates killed. And also note I never said he wasnt guilty or even remotly justified.
And you are an idiot if you think politics has nothing to do with this
Compare and contrast Hasan with Bales
Hasan
Nov 5, 2009 attacks
Oct 12 2010 Article 32 hearing 11months & 7days later
Jun 12 2012 Estimated date of trial 2yrs & 7months ahter attacks
Now do you really think the governemnt is going to let this drag on until January of 2015 before the trial even starts in the case of Robert Bales? All reports indicate Bales' Article 32 hearing will be in by the end of this month, not sometime in Febuary next year
lujlp at March 25, 2012 7:51 AM
Lujlp says - Wolfman, blow me. I'm a vet as well. Note I said military culture, not US military culture.
Such tap dancing is beneath you, Lujlp. Further, if you are a vet, you know how much and how often Laws of Land Warfare, Rules of Engagement and the moral imperative for a soldier to refuse to obey immoral, illegal and unjust orders are hammered into the troops. If you were infantry, it was constant. Further, one cannot help but justify actions by mitigating them with explanations. If Bales actions are the "end result of military culture...coupled with political indeifference for soldiers needs and health" then by definition you are saying Bales could be any of us. And what Bales did is not something any of us could or would do. There is no difference between that statement and a feminist saying "This womans rape was a result of patriarchal culture and a societal belief that women are mens property," in which case you would be all over her like white on rice and a glass of milk on a paper plate in a snowstorm. And you would be right to do so, because it would be bullshit and a slur on all men.
Lujlp says - And you are an idiot if you think politics has nothing to do with this
OOOOOOKay, and when did I say politics has nothing to do with this and in what respect is that pertinent? To your assertion, you bet politics has something to do with this. Im wondering myself, if Hassan was not terrorism but "workplace violence," is this "workplace violence" too? I have a feeling it won't be called that. But I still wonder how that makes the actions of a lone freak (if in fact he is guilty of what he is accused of) the moral equivalent of an entire murderous religion, which is the matter asserted by apologists for Islam. When you assert that Bales actions are the result of military culture, lack of care, blah, blah, you support the case of these apologists by offering evidence of a culture as dedicated to the killig of muslims as muslim culture is dedicated to killing everyone else, and that is simply a false moral equivalence.
Lujlp says - If your enenmy is the emotion equivelent of your kids you wont fire and will get your squadmates killed.
That is something each soldier has to work out for himself, but in every case there are circumstances to be considered around the event. If I am entering a house as a memeber of a squad, and a kid makes a move I take as being a move for a weapon, I have to, for the sake of my squad, do what has to be done to neutralize the threat. If in the final analysis I am wrong, we consider the totality of the circumstances. Even if I am wrong, there is a world, a planet, a galaxy of difference between that and going into a village at night and gunning people down.
The WolfMan at March 25, 2012 9:11 AM
In a perfect world, Robert Bales will be handed over to Afghan government to be tried for the crimes he may or may not have committed.
I wouldn't turn a dog over to a government that's willing to execute one of its citizens simply because he changed religion, let alone a fellow American.
In a perfect world, 1000 years from now Afghani mothers would frighten their children into behaving simply by saying keep this up, and the Americans will come and get you.
I R A Darth Aggie at March 25, 2012 10:06 AM
Sam, please join with Eric in taking your moral equivalence and shoving it up your ass.
Bob at March 26, 2012 7:38 PM
What Bob said.
Dave B at March 26, 2012 8:14 PM
Leave a comment