Should You Take Ecstasy To Improve Your Marriage?
Interesting piece by Brian David Earp, a research fellow at Oxford's Uehiro Centre for Practical Ethics, co-authored by Julian Savulescu and Anders Sandberg. "Not so fast," they say, probably, in part because they are putting this out through a university. They advise that "ectasy has very complex effects on the brain, not all of which are fully understood, and many of which can be dangerous."
I took ecstasy in New York, when I was feeling lost and having a hard time, and I believe it helped me. But I have to concede that they are right, that you don't really know what you're getting outside of a research lab.
Here is what they write about what they call "the broader context" of the marriage part of the question:
We think that modern relationships are as fragile as they are in large part because there is a mismatch between our psycho-sexual natures (designed by evolution to handle the mating arrangements of our ancestors on the African savannah) and our modern relationship values (designed for very different reasons, under completely different conditions). In short, we weren't built for lifelong monogamy, and it's no huge surprise that we struggle to pull it off. So what should we do?There are many possible answers. One route we could take is to re-consider our values - maybe lifelong love and sexual exclusivity are not something we should be striving for in the first place. There are some arguments for this position, and some may find them convincing. But most will not. Recent surveys show that a large majority of unmarried people still wish to meet at the altar with someone they love, and a raft of evidence shows that successful, committed relationships are conducive to well-being, increasing physical and emotional health, and even longevity. Strong marriages are also in the best interests of children, as we take the time to show in our Philosophy & Technology piece. Accordingly, we suggest that it may be time to explore other possibilities: boosting our psycho-biologies to "rise" to the level of our values. We call this the neuroenhancement of human relationships, and it's where all the talk about "love drugs" comes into play.
Note that the goal here is not to kindle some arbitrary attraction out of thin air like love potions do in fairy tales, but to help existing love survive the test of time. Scientists do not yet understand the attraction system well enough to allow us to conjecture whether love potions of the fairy-tale variety are even possible. And even if they were, they would pose a number of moral problems since they could create inauthentic relationships with no real grounding in the actual compatibilities of the individuals involved. In contrast, our arguments examined the possibility of using love drugs to make authentic relationships last.







Amy, why would you take ecstasy as opposed to going to a doctor for a drug to combat the issues you were having? Not being judgemental, just curious.
causticf at October 30, 2013 7:29 AM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2013/10/30/should_you_take.html#comment-4017001">comment from causticfI needed to look into myself and not have a therapist ask me about my childhood. (I was lost about who I was and the work I was doing.) I had met Terrence McKenna in New York (and kept running into him about every other time he and we Advice Ladies did radio) and I'd also met Os Janiger in Los Angeles (through Tim Leary and gerontologist Roy Walford) and came to see the merits of taking LSD and other drugs for alleviating emotional and psychological problems. And it did help.
I also read McKenna's helpful and interesting book, The Archaic Revival: Speculations on Psychedelic Mushrooms, the Amazon, Virtual Reality, UFOs, Evolution, Shamanism, the Rebirth of the Goddess, and the End of History.
A page about Os: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oscar_Janiger
Amy Alkon
at October 30, 2013 7:42 AM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2013/10/30/should_you_take.html#comment-4017005">comment from Amy AlkonAlso, if you'll see the link to my private sessions above, I do one session with people because I help them solve their problem and give them ways to deal with setbacks that are likely to befall them. Therapists make money by NOT solving your problem, by keeping you coming back.
Amy Alkon
at October 30, 2013 7:43 AM
Take the research about the mortality benefits of marriage with a grain of salt. Take the ecstasy if you want.
Beth O'Donnell at October 30, 2013 7:44 AM
Drugs are a crutch for people who can't handle reality.
Conversely, reality is a crutch for people who can't handle drugs.
Me? Cannabis all the way baby, and some wine on the side. Don't need nothin' else.
Putting strange chemicals in your body can fuck you up in strange ways. Why risk it? As a friend once told me, "Pot is nature's way of saying 'high'!"
Flynne at October 30, 2013 8:02 AM
Personal experience? No. The following depression can be very deep. Plus, the feelings it elicits aren't real. Plus, maybe it's just me, but when I was on E (or anything else) I did not want sex. I was just all in my head. In fact, it pretty much killed all sensation in the genitals.
Plus, it can cause permanent changes in brain chemistry. A lot of coke users end up with lifelong anxiety issues. A lot of E users can have problems with depression the rest of their lives. Worth it? Not so much.
momof4 at October 30, 2013 8:53 AM
it's very common for people, usually teenagers pr young adults, to go thru a phase of finding themselves, especially, like amy and myself, if we did not have strong parental role models. i did pot daily for nearly 2 years in high school. my friends did it, too, so it was partly a social thing. i gradually dropped pot during college, as i continued to find myself. didn't need it any more and preferred life, and myself, without it.
Jim Simon at October 30, 2013 9:27 AM
or, you know... we could use chemistry naturally occurring in the body.
It is my feeling [and I'd pay for the research if I won the lottery] that much of this boils down to the use of barrier contraception, and hormonal contraception.
We bond to each other chemically... unless we can't. Both types of contro alter how things generally work, in the brain and body of the couple.
This talk of african savannahs ignores the idea that back then, we didn't live to test anything long term.
The crux is, we need and wish to control when we have kids an how many, and currently the ways of doing this are either to trick a woman's body into thinking it's preggers, or blocking the swimmers and all that chemistry form interchanging at all... both situations not normal over the long run.
Curious on Amy's take on this, because of the IUD... which my understanding is not for every woman. OTOH, the RSUIG method studied in india to block [kill] the swimmers in men, but NOT the rest of the chemistry, seem promising... but will prolly never get past the various governmental hurdles in India, much less the US. There's no money in it... and it would also trouble many of the narratives about who controls pregnancy.
SwissArmyD at October 30, 2013 10:28 AM
At my advanced age, I have come to believe that there are two things that make us crazy and or sick. The first is genetics, and the second is your environment.
People evolved to eat a relatively natural diet, low in sugar and processed crap, and they need enough sunshine to manufacture sufficient vitamin d.
They also apparently, according to research derive a number of benefits from the exchange of bodily fluids with a loved one. Unprotected sex is the best, and only kind I am willing to have.
My husband got a vasectomy 6 weeks after our second child was born, which in retrospect was probably the best thing for my long term health and well being.
The older I get the more allergies I have, and the more foods I have to avoid in order to feel well.
I am on very few medications for my age, and I don't think recreational drugs other than an occasional glass of wine or cup of coffee will make my marriage better.
I may have some pretty good genes for longevity, if I don't screw it up with an unhealthy lifestyle.
Isab at October 30, 2013 2:41 PM
I knew a couple who did this.
Long story short, they became addicts, as in 6 hits a night addicts; they started exhibiting crazy behavior like calling us 17 times in a row at 2am, showing up if we didn't answer the phone, coming up with crazy ideas and inventions,(the last one involved harvesting serotonin from dead bodies as a depression treatment) and getting angry at us for having other friends.
We don't hang around with them anymore. It's sad, because we were friends with them for 20 years.
I miss them. Or rather, who they were.
wtf at October 30, 2013 5:40 PM
In short, we weren't built for lifelong monogamy, and it's no huge surprise that we struggle to pull it off.
Monogamy is surprising easy to pull off when a) you weren't promiscuous before marriage and b) you live in a community where a married person flirting would be perceived as creepy.
Sorer Bveito at October 30, 2013 8:52 PM
Not sure about ecstasy for relationships but docs say you can pop
shrooms for personality!
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at October 31, 2013 7:30 AM
@Sorer Bveito
"Monogamy is surprising easy to pull off when a) you weren't promiscuous before marriage "
Could you provide some evidence for that?
Thanks!
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at October 31, 2013 7:33 AM
"Putting strange chemicals in your body can fuck you up in strange ways."
Perhaps not this hippie chick, but, "Hippie chick complains about HGH in beef. Buys weed from unknown source, is OK with that."
Just in this thread, cognitive dissonance is alarming.
Radwaste at October 31, 2013 2:42 PM
Leave a comment