The Government Should Stay Out Of My Stomach And Yours
Wave bye-bye to the sprinkles atop your frozen yogurt!
Now they're banning trans fast -- specifically, trans fat-containing partially hydrogenated oils. Walter Olson blogs at Overlawyered:
Pushed by a lawsuit, the Food and Drug Administration has followed through and banned the use of trans fats in processed food: producers have three years to phase out the substance. I've got a new piece at Cato making a few basic points: the move is sheer paternalism, it's setting a precedent (against voluntary consumer assumption of even small risks) that activists are eager to roll out against other ingredients like salt and sugar, it's not popular with the public (this poll finds a plurality, not majority, going along, while this one finds majorities opposed). And voluntary consumer adjustments (trans fat consumption is down by an estimated 85 percent) have already cut Americans' average daily intake to half of what the American Heart Association recommends.Then there's the sadly ironic history of the whole subject: trans fats were avidly promoted at the time by the same sorts of public health activists and government nutritionists who now push for a ban.
Ridiculous move by government. I've eaten very low carb since March of 2009 -- against the bad and unscientific advice by government (to eat a high-carb, lowfat -- and unhealthy!) diet.
Eating against the government's unscientific, bad advice, I have the health stats of an elite athlete -- while spending much of the day in a chair, weeping over a keyboard (uh, writing).
I generally avoid eating anything with flour in it, but if I decide to have a trans fat-containing cookie at a party, it's none of the government's damn business. Or should be none of the government's damn business.
Walter Olson also blogs at Cato:
The public is also perfectly capable of recognizing and acting on nutritional advances on its own. Trans fats have gone out of style and consumption has dropped by 85 percent as consumers have shunned them....Even if you never plan to consume a smidgen of trans fat ever again, note well: many public health advocates are itching for the FDA to limit allowable amounts of salt, sugar, caffeine, and so forth in food products. Many see this as their big pilot project and test case.







Dear advocates of this ban: Please point out to me the clause in the Constitution that grants the federal government the authority to enforce this. (And if you point at the Commerce Clause, I'll smack you.)
Cousin Dave at June 17, 2015 8:42 AM
Amy, that first overlawyered link is not working... It has part of this site addy, part of theirs.
Working one;
http://overlawyered.com/2015/06/fda-trans-fat-palm-gmo-soybean-oil/
it makes sense to me that they pushed these things before banning them years later...
the key is that they presume to make our decisions for us... and the bovine huddled masses, can't be f-ed to do anything about it.
SwissArmyD at June 17, 2015 8:45 AM
Thanks - fixed.
Amy Alkon at June 17, 2015 8:58 AM
When the government is footing the bill for your healthcare (ObamaCare), it gets a say in what you eat, smoke, and drink; and how much you exercise. Just wait, we'll have mandatory calisthenics in the workplace before long.
Conan the Grammarian at June 17, 2015 10:26 AM
Many excellent points. Government has hectored us about our diets for years, but somehow there's an obesity epidemic and only Mrs. Obama can rescue us. It's intrusive, offensive and at the end of the day, scary.
Another Amy at June 17, 2015 11:12 AM
What's the fuss. You can still sprinkle Splenda and broccoli on your yogurt.
Andrew_M_Garland at June 17, 2015 2:58 PM
Caffeine?!
You'll have to pry my espresso cup from my cold dead hands you bastards!
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at June 17, 2015 4:53 PM
"...the move is sheer paternalism..."
Why paternalism? Why isn't it maternalism? Big momma is watching you!
Ken R at June 17, 2015 7:51 PM
I see what they're doing. With the legislation of marijuana the prisons will have vacancies. When salt becomes illegal the problem will be solved and dealers will be back in business. Win-win.
Ray Johnson at June 18, 2015 6:05 AM
Grrrrr legalization... Damned type ahead.
Ray Johnson at June 18, 2015 6:06 AM
Leave a comment