The Rid Carpet
I'm a 30-something gay guy. When I moved to a new city five years ago, I knew nobody except two female co-workers, who became my first friends. I have since met wonderful, talented, artistic people who are more my style. I no longer work with these ladies, and I'm just not interested in hanging out with them anymore. When they call to get together, I keep saying I'm busy, but they're not getting the picture. How do I break up with them without being mean?
--Trapped
When you break up with a romantic partner, there are comforting cliches you can trot out, like "It's not you; it's me," "You deserve better," and "We can still be friends." When you break up with a friend, where do you go with that? "We can still be people who hide behind mall kiosks so they don't have to speak to each other"?
It helps to understand the underpinnings of friendship. We like to think of ourselves as rational and discerning people with very good taste, and naturally, we believe this shapes our choice of friends. In fact, personality psychologist Mitja Back and his colleagues find that a major driver of whom we're friends with is "mere proximity" -- living on the same block, working together, or, in Back's study, being randomly assigned seats next to each other in a college class.
Location, location, location! Really special, huh?
Still, maybe you feel a little guilty about exiling these ladies from your life, because you used them to have some somebodies around when you knew nobody. However, they hung out with you willingly. It's not like you were some odious character they were forced to go to brunch with at gunpoint.
The kindest approach, of course, is to keep distancing yourself and hope they get the message or just give up on trying to get together. You do say that the "take the hint!" approach hasn't been working. But are their calls and texts so screechingly bothersome that it's worth it to go all rip-the-Band-Aid-off? If you decide it is, you could say, "You guys have been so kind to me, and I've enjoyed our times together, but I've gone through some personal changes, and I don't think we're such a great match anymore."
Be prepared: They may press you to tell them more. For maximum kindness, stick to this sort of vague statement. Don't go all truthful on them: They were human placeholders, the sidewalk furniture of friends, like curbside chairs you dragged home so you wouldn't have to ask your dates, "Hey, wanna stand in my living room and watch Netflix?"
For pages and pages of "science-help" from me, buy my latest book, "Unf*ckology: A Field Guide to Living with Guts and Confidence." It lays out the PROCESS of transforming to live w/confidence.








This is the worst advice Amy has ever given. She’s suggesting that he ghost his “former” friends, hoping they’ll catch on to the “former” part. This is cruel, and cowardly. To behave with integrity, LW should be honest that his life has changed, and has begun to fill up with people he has more in common with. This allows the former friends to stop spinning their wheels, and also to not wonder if they did or said something to offend LW.
Jeff at December 6, 2019 1:40 PM
Jeff, your advice is perfect. I love the way you worded it.
Jen at December 6, 2019 4:33 PM
"They were human placeholders, the sidewalk furniture of friends, like curbside chairs you dragged home" Wow. Treat people like old discarded furniture. This is what our society has come to. Callous, indifferent, self-centered, self-serving, UGLY excuses for human beings. It's a shame these women invested themselves in helping him through a very lonely time. They obviously thought more of the friendship than he did.
Jan at December 7, 2019 8:30 AM
Jeff's got some good ideas. I hope LW sees his comment and goes with his advice.
Katiana at December 7, 2019 9:16 AM
Jan: Amy's advice is NOT to say those things, even if they were true.
Ian at December 10, 2019 4:45 PM
Ian, her advice is not to say it explicitly or directly, but unless they're idiots, the message is clear - "when I was in need, you were my friends, but I don't feel any obligation to honor that." The time will likely come when his more fashionable, trendy friends decide they've outgrown him, and he is on the other end of this (because birds of a feather.) When that day comes, I hope he writed to Amy and I read it, so I can LAUGH at him. He's a shallow, inconsiderate person. Those women's willingness to be his friends when such freindship didn't represent a feather in their social climbing hats is a value to which he is blind.
bw1 at December 12, 2019 5:29 PM
Jan, she was obviously joking, and it was hilarious.
I like Amy’s advice. I would never even tell these we aren’t such a great match anymore. Would instead reply with smiley faces two days late to all texts and say life’s really busy with work and boyfriend and it seems impossible to find time to leave (whatever neighborhood) but hope you guys are well :) They’ll move on.
Mary at December 17, 2019 7:35 PM
Mary, is that how you would like to be treated, if the roles were reversed? If you’ve ever gotten the distinct feeling you’re being avoided, and confused as to why, then MAYBE you’ll understand why your advice is so bad.
Jeff at December 18, 2019 3:32 PM
Leave a comment